Tooth Fairy Pennies

Ready to ship in 3–5 days · Every penny ships in an envelope made for under the pillow
The Tooth Fairy

Leave a little magic under the pillow.

Tooth Fairy pennies pressed on genuine pre-1982 copper and hand-polished in our North Carolina shop. Engrave your child's name and tooth date on the back, and that first wiggly tooth becomes a keepsake they'll keep forever.

From $6 · Personalized engraving · Fairy dust · Tooth Fairy card and extras

Tooth Fairy with Fairy Dust pressed penny
Genuine pre-1982 copper
Ships in a pillow-ready envelope
Ready to ship in 3–5 days

Three designs

Pick your Tooth Fairy

Each pressed one at a time. Any of them can be engraved with a name and date on the back.

Tooth Fairy with Fairy Dust pressed penny Bestseller

Tooth Fairy with Fairy Dust

The Tooth Fairy sprinkling her magic dust. Add real sparkle with our fine fairy-dust glitter finish.

$6 · fairy dust +$1

Choose this penny
Tooth Fairy with Wand pressed penny Great for little ones

Tooth Fairy with Wand

A smiling tooth with a star wand. A cheerful first-tooth surprise for younger kids.

$6

Choose this penny
Personalized Tooth Fairy Keepsake pressed penny Made for engraving

Personalized Tooth Fairy Keepsake

Designed to carry your child's name and the date they lost their tooth on the back.

$6

Choose this penny

Make it theirs

Add these when you choose your penny:

Name & tooth dateEngraved on the back · +$6
Fairy dustFine sparkle glitter on the penny · +$1
Tooth Fairy cardMounted on our hand-drawn card · +$2
Jar of fairy dustA tiny corked jar of star sparkles · +$3
Wax sealOur crowned-tooth seal · +$1
Official Visit stickerProof the Tooth Fairy stopped by · +$3
Official Visit from the Tooth Fairy seal

How the Tooth Fairy's visit works

Order when the wiggling starts, so the penny is waiting when the tooth comes out.

  1. 1Pick a design

    Choose the Tooth Fairy your child will love.

  2. 2Add the magic

    Engrave a name and date, add fairy dust, a card or extras.

  3. 3We press & ship

    Hand-polished and on its way in 3–5 days.

  4. 4Slip it under the pillow

    Its envelope makes the swap easy in the dark.

Two engraved Tooth Fairy pennies, for Everett and Julia, on gold hand-drawn Tooth Fairy cards with a jar of fairy dust, wax seal and Official Visit sticker

Drawn by hand · +$2

Add our Tooth Fairy card

Have your penny mounted on our gold Tooth Fairy card, ready to leave under the pillow and keep in the baby book. Every star, swirl and letter is drawn by hand in our North Carolina shop.

Choose your penny

Collect every tooth

Kids lose about twenty baby teeth. Keep each penny, with its name and date, together in a penny book that grows with them.

See penny books

Questions from parents

Will it arrive in time?

Tooth Fairy pennies are ready to ship in 3–5 days, plus shipping time. Ordering when a tooth starts wiggling is the safest bet.

Is it a real penny?

Yes. Every one is pressed on a genuine pre-1982 copper penny and polished by hand.

What can I engrave on the back?

Most families choose the child's name and the date the tooth came out. You'll enter it when you add engraving.

How does it ship?

In a small envelope sized to tuck right under the pillow, so the Tooth Fairy doesn't have to wrap anything.

The tooth is gone. The penny stays forever.

Choose a Tooth Fairy penny

Questions? hello@thepennydepot.com